• <acronym id="11166"></acronym>
    <code id="11166"></code><acronym id="11166"></acronym>
  • <dd id="11166"><u id="11166"></u></dd>

      <var id="11166"></var>

      1. Advertisement

        Letters to the Editor: A ‘right to literacy’ in schools is meaningless unless children read at home

        First day of school
        Parents and students line up outside their new classrooms as they wait for school to begin at Thomas Jefferson Elementary School in Burbank.
        (Dan Watson / Burbank Leader)

        To the editor: As a retired reading specialist, I was pleased by your editorial on the federal lawsuit claiming that it is a constitutional right for all students to be able to read competently. I’d like to make a few points.

        You state that changes in the curriculum could be a weapon in the so-called reading wars between phonics and whole-language programs. It is not a case of trying one or the other. Both are necessary given the structure of the English language, in which 85% of the words are phonetically regular. Ignoring the other 15% would be unwise.

        The second point is related to the role of the schools in teaching reading, not just the mechanics but the act of reading fluently.

        More than 100 years ago Edward Thorndike, an early faculty member at Columbia University’s school of education, claimed that students learn to read mostly at home. Schools can provide basic tools, but without home and community support, reading programs likely will not succeed.


        Robert W. Kopfstein, Bonsall, Calif.


        To the editor: Your editorial supporting the notion of a constitutional “right to literacy” prompts additional questions in the age of COVID-19.

        Our Constitution is filled with prohibitions, but very few, if any, affirmative obligations for individuals.


        When I was teaching constitutional law I would give the example of the person who collapses on the sidewalk near you, and you are the only observer. Do you have an affirmative obligation to do anything, if only to call 911? Is there a right to be intentionally cruel and do nothing as a fellow citizen dies in front of you?

        In today’s crisis we could easily ask the same question in different form. Does a president have a right to order meat packing plants to reopen while at the same time refusing to create the necessary safety rules? Do homeless people have a right to shelter? Do the starving have a right to eat?

        What good does it mean to have a “right to literacy” if you can’t feed your family or have a roof over your head?

        If there is anything good to come out of this health crisis, it will be a reconsideration of the proper role of government. A fully functioning government safety net may be required by our Constitution. Wouldn’t that be a pleasing antidote to our current leadership vacuum?


        Roger Lowenstein, Beverly Hills

        A cure for the common opinion

        Get thought-provoking perspectives with our weekly newsletter.

        You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
        温宿| 元谋| 安溪| 西安| 昭通| 沙雅| 太仆寺旗| 莆田| 镇原| 楚雄| 永昌| 威宁| 石泉| 桐城| 上思| 和政| 灵宝| 叶县| 烟台| 河津| 临夏| 庐江| 清丰| 江浦| 崆峒| 包头| 南陵| 鄂伦春旗| 加格达奇| 商丘| 罗城| 奇台| 勐海| 满洲里| 察隅| 广河| 昭苏| 清涧| 迁西| 田林| 密云上甸子| 忻城| 罗城| 镇江| 永清| 深圳| 光泽| 徐家汇| 乌审旗| 冷湖| 武胜| 黑山| 汝南| 泗阳| 来凤| 黑山头| 萧山| 平原| 沛县| 安乡| 信阳| 卫辉| 商洛| 新晃| 西峡| 凌云| 乌恰| 太平| 一八五团| 永福| 青州| 平凉| 光山| 神农架| 礼县| 渭源| 赤城| 赞皇| 图里河| 三门峡| 隆林| 昆山| 辽阳| 南丰| 泗水| 都江堰| 前郭| 武冈| 八达岭| 大足| 方城| 咸丰| 北海| 萝北| 莫力达瓦旗| 沁水| 深泽| 平南| 娄底| 青浦| 新昌| 赤壁| 平舆| 长寿| 宣城| 丰镇| 昭平| 延川| 肥西| 石河子| 临汾| 濮阳| 富民| 博湖| 定日| 张掖| 果洛| 高唐| 乌鲁木齐牧试站| 河卡| 齐河| 本溪县| 莫索湾| 靖江| 杭锦旗| 南海| 崆峒| 惠阳| 宁乡| 宁陕| 漳平| 天全| 杭锦后旗| 巢湖| 海城| 宝应| 民权| 惠农| 遂昌| 通道| 浦城| 平安| 大佘太| 潍坊| 万盛| 宁远| 班戈| 南皮| 瑞安| 庄河| 荣成| 乳源| 逊克| 汤阴| 砚山| 融安| 杭锦旗| 乐至| 荣昌| 惠来| 南靖| 泰顺| 济阳| 广宗| 户县| 兰西| 上犹| 金坛| 巴林右旗| 奈曼旗| 凤县| 施秉| 青县| 公安| 平武| 九台| 六盘山| 高阳| 扶沟| 连云港| 青浦| 固阳| 喀左| 祁县| 延边| 松桃| 高淳| 庆云| 灵川| 舒城| 凉城| 大冶| 林甸| 安阳| 惠阳| 西乌珠穆沁旗| 八达岭| 石渠| 陈巴尔虎旗| 巫溪| 营口| 白日乌拉| 长丰| 温岭| 桂阳| 沅陵| 安阳| 古县| 达尔罕茂明安联合旗| 引水船| 丰南| 中环| 浠水| 保定| 咸丰| 柳河| 红安| 德钦| 石首| 鄂托克前旗| 通州| 郧县| 资溪| 辽阳| 建平县| 禹州| 康县| 临邑| 安国| 涿州| 太华山| 通河| 信宜| 睢阳区| 神农架| 贵南| 本溪| 太和| 安平| 邳州| 海丰| 奇台| 宁陵| 屏南| 洞口| 文山| 长清| 商洛| 黄龙| 八里罕| 无锡| 察尔汉| 海宁| 镇平| 那仁宝力格| 云梦| 霸州| 西昌| 古田| 滦南| 云霄| 五原| 平舆| 绵阳| 北票| 河口| 纳溪| 林西| 霍州| 尼木| 梁山| 索县| 桓台| 祁县| 德惠| 蕉岭| 道县| 武陟| 太原北郊| 武穴| 洋县| 广汉| 吉木乃| 白水| 安庆| 松原| 琼结| 宜宾县| 临沭| 关岭| 桂林农试站| 启东| 高安| 常德| 花都| 富顺| 黄山站| 富川| 祁东| 卫辉| 山阴| 公主岭| 南川| 湘阴| 太白| 黄平| 丰县| 贡山| 左贡| 雅江| 刚察| 嘉禾| 剑川| 临河| 潼关| 曲麻莱| 三穗| 弥勒| 上思| 邻水| 旌德| 狮泉河| 扬中| 齐河| 富锦| 赫章| 浮山| 万源| 黎城| 深泽| 永春| 东宁| 霍山| 鸡西| 玛纳斯| 上川岛| 万荣| 海原| 仪征| 永泰| 盘县| 江油| 攸县| 嵊山| 乌什| 金昌| 乌拉特中旗| 天池| 萝北| 白云| 金昌| 镇雄| 惠农| 栾城| 濉溪| 珊瑚岛| 蒙城| 阜新| 宽城| 石岛| 淖毛湖| 红原| 南涧| 马龙| 贵港| 景洪电站| 徐水| 德惠| 怒江| 郎溪| 梁山| 怀安| 丰镇| 仁怀| 佳县| 甘孜| 和田| 仁化| 旬阳| 新洲| 金川| 苏尼特左旗| 嵩明| 望奎| 浩尔吐| 五道梁| 蕲春| 上高| 武义| 新建| 盐都| 无棣| 和顺| 维西| 枞阳| 临猗| 眉山| 栖霞| 郫县| 赵县